Making the ask land
Step 1 / 4·Six principles of persuasion — and the ethical line
0/4 steps done
Learning objectives — after this module you will:
- Use the six principles of persuasion honestly
- Structure an ask in four parts
- Frame the proposal around what the listener cares about
Six principles of persuasion — and the ethical line
Understand the mechanism, and know where manipulation starts.
Robert Cialdini catalogued six principles that make people say yes. They aren't tricks — they're real psychological shortcuts that work even when you know about them. What matters is whether you use them to state a TRUE thing, or to manufacture a false one.
Six principles, used honestly and used badly
| Principle | Used honestly | Becomes manipulation when |
|---|---|---|
| Reciprocity | You genuinely help, with no strings; people naturally want to reciprocate | You help to create a debt, then call it in exactly when refusing is hardest |
| Commitment & consistency | Start with a small step they can genuinely agree to | You get a small commitment and then read it as agreement to the whole thing |
| Social proof | 'Three plants already run this process — here are their numbers' | 'Everyone's doing this' when in fact one site has trialled it |
| Authority | State the basis: what you know, where it comes from, where you're unsure | Using jargon and titles so people are too intimidated to question you |
| Liking | Find real common ground and credit their real contribution | Empty flattery to soften someone up before the ask |
| Scarcity | Name real constraints: the budget closes on the 30th, the partner holds the price to next quarter | Manufacturing time pressure so people can't think it through |
The daylight test
Before using any principle, ask: if this person knew exactly why I'm saying this, would they be fine with it? If the answer is no, it's manipulation — and inside an organisation, manipulation that gets noticed destroys the most durable source of influence you have, your credibility.
Key takeaway: The six principles are real; the ethical line is whether you use them to state a true thing or manufacture a false one.